Local GuidesRoofing Materials

How to choose between metal and shingle roofing in Des Moines

Choosing between metal and shingle roofing in Des Moines comes down to how long you plan to stay, how your roof handles hail and snow, and what the upfront difference buys you.

Residential roofline in Des Moines showing neighboring shingle and metal roofs under a clear sky

The short answer: metal vs shingle roofing in Des Moines

Choosing between metal and shingle roofing in Des Moines comes down to how long you plan to stay in the home, how the roof handles hail and snow, and what the higher upfront cost of metal buys over time. Neither material is the right answer for every house, and the condition of the roof deck, the pitch, and the ventilation matter as much as the material on top.

Asphalt shingles are the default material on most Des Moines homes: familiar to every roofer, straightforward to repair in sections, and lower in upfront cost. Metal roofing costs more at installation and typically lasts longer, sheds snow readily, and resists wind uplift differently than shingles. The sections below compare the two on cost direction, lifespan guide figures, weather performance, and upkeep, so the choice rests on your roof and your plans rather than on a slogan.

If the roof is already leaking or near the end of its life, the material decision usually follows an inspection. A roof inspection looks at the shingles or panels, the flashing, the vents, and the attic signs that tell whether repair or roof replacement fits.

Metal vs shingle roof cost in Des Moines, Iowa

Metal roofing costs more upfront than asphalt shingles in Des Moines, and the gap depends on the panel type, the complexity of the roof, and whether old roofing comes off first. Standing-seam panels sit at the higher end of the metal range, while exposed-fastener panels sit lower. Shingle costs vary with the shingle type, the number of layers removed, and the condition of the decking found underneath.

This guide does not publish prices. Dated third-party market figures for both materials, with sources and conflicts shown, are gathered in the roof replacement cost guide on this site. Those figures are market data from other publishers, not ZT Contracting LLC prices, and they move with material and labor markets.

When comparing quotes for either material, compare the same scope: tear-off or overlay, decking repair, ice barrier, underlayment, ventilation, and flashing. A lower figure that leaves out tear-off or flashing is not the same job as a higher figure that includes them.

Which roof lasts longer in Des Moines, IA?

Published guide figures put architectural asphalt shingles at roughly 20 to 30 years, three-tab shingles at 15 to 20 years, ribbed or exposed-fastener metal at 30 to 40 years, and standing-seam metal at 40 to 70 years. These are general guide figures from third-party guides, not promises about any particular roof. Hail exposure, freeze-thaw stress, ventilation, and upkeep move real roofs earlier or later within and beyond those spans.

On that basis, metal generally lasts longer than shingles in Des Moines. The practical question is whether the extra years matter for your plans. A homeowner planning to stay for decades may value them. A homeowner planning to sell within a few years may weigh upfront cost and condition at sale more heavily.

Age alone does not decide a roof's future. A 22-year-old shingle roof with sound decking and no leaks may have useful life left, while a younger roof with failed flashing or poor ventilation may need attention sooner. Shingle roofing and metal roofing both reward periodic inspection, whatever the guide figures say.

How each material handles Des Moines weather

In the 1996-2025 NOAA Storm Prediction Center record, the core of the Des Moines hail season falls between April 14 and September 6, peaking in June; an older radar-area climatology covering 1980-2006 puts the peak in May instead. Within 15 miles of the city, 100 hail days have been recorded since 2010, the largest stones reaching 3.25 inches in 2021, with the latest hail day on October 8, 2026. Metal and shingles meet the same hail record and answer it differently.

Metal panels tend to dent visibly in hail while often staying watertight unless seams or fasteners are affected. Dents are easiest to see in raking light. Shingles bruise: the impact knocks granules loose and can fracture the mat underneath, sometimes with little visible change from the ground. Impact-resistant Class 4 shingles exist as a shingle option; there is no code mandate for them in Des Moines, and no verified discount or payback figure is published in this guide. After any hail storm, a storm damage roof repair assessment looks at the full scope rather than one slope.

Winter brings a different test. Des Moines averages 36.5 inches of snow (NOAA 1991-2020), and the City's design criteria include a 33 psf ground snow load, 115 mph wind speed, and a 0°F winter design temperature. Metal sheds snow readily, which can mean snow sliding from the roof edge. Shingles hold snow longer, which keeps loads on the roof through freeze-thaw cycles. Either way, an ice barrier is required in Des Moines, and attic ventilation and air sealing shape how each material weathers winter.

What about home value?

No reliable Des Moines-specific figure connects a roofing material to a resale value change, and this guide does not invent one. What a buyer or appraiser sees is the condition of the roof, its remaining life, and the documentation behind the work, more than the material name alone.

A newer roof in good condition, whichever material, generally presents better than an aging roof near the end of its life. If resale is part of the decision, weigh the roof's condition at the time of sale and the records of the work done, and treat material choice as one factor among several rather than the deciding one.

Metal roofing pros and cons in Des Moines, Iowa

Metal roofing suits homeowners who value longevity and snow shedding and who accept the higher upfront cost and the look of panels on their street.

Pros

  • Longer guide lifespan - standing-seam figures run 40 to 70 years in third-party guides.
  • Snow shedding - snow slides from metal more readily than from shingles.
  • Wind and hail behavior - panels resist uplift differently than shingle tabs, and hail usually dents rather than punctures.
  • Fewer seams on simple roofs - long panels suit straightforward roof planes.

Cons

  • Higher upfront cost - materials and specialized installation run above shingles.
  • Visible denting - hail dents show, even when the roof stays watertight.
  • Noise in rain and hail - some homeowners notice more sound, depending on the assembly and attic.
  • Repair matching - panel and color matching can be harder years later.

Shingle roofing pros and cons in Des Moines, IA

Shingle roofing suits homeowners who value lower upfront cost, a familiar look, and straightforward section repairs, and who accept a shorter guide lifespan.

Pros

  • Lower upfront cost - shingles are the lower-cost option at installation.
  • Familiar appearance - the standard look on most Des Moines streets.
  • Section repairs - damaged areas can often be repaired without replacing the whole roof.
  • Wide installer familiarity - shingle work is standard practice for residential roofers.

Cons

  • Shorter guide lifespan - architectural figures run 20 to 30 years.
  • Hail bruising - impacts can fracture the mat with little visible sign from the ground.
  • Granule loss over time - aging shingles shed granules and dry out, which shortens remaining life.
  • Snow retention - shingles hold snow through freeze-thaw cycles, adding load and ice-dam exposure.

Common mistakes when choosing a roof material

Choosing on upfront cost alone is the most common mistake. A lower installation figure with a shorter life can cost more across two replacements than a higher figure with a longer life, and the reverse is true for a short stay. Match the material to the time horizon.

Other mistakes include ignoring ventilation and attic conditions, which affect both materials; assuming a new roof can go over old roofing without checking layer and condition rules with a roofer and the City; and skipping the ice barrier discussion on a reroof, where the barrier is required in Des Moines. Pressure to decide on the spot after a storm is a warning sign, not a reason to hurry.

When to call a professional

Call a roofer when the roof is leaking, when shingles or panels show damage after a storm, or when age and wear make the repair-or-replace question real. An inspection gives the material choice a factual base: the deck, the flashing, the ventilation, and the remaining life of what is already there. Call ZT Contracting LLC at (515) 385-2566 to arrange a roof inspection and talk through metal and shingle options for your roof.

Frequently asked questions

Is metal or shingle roofing better in Des Moines IA?

Neither material wins for every home. Metal generally lasts longer and sheds snow, while shingles cost less upfront and repair in sections. The right choice depends on how long you plan to stay, the roof's condition, and the scope of the work.

How much more does a metal roof cost in Des Moines, Iowa?

Metal costs more upfront than shingles, and the gap depends on panel type, roof complexity, and tear-off scope. Dated third-party market figures with sources and conflicts are in the roof replacement cost guide on this site. Those are market figures, not ZT Contracting LLC prices.

Does metal roofing increase home value in Des Moines IA?

No reliable Des Moines-specific figure was found for a resale value change from roofing material. Buyers and appraisers weigh the roof's condition, remaining life, and work records more than the material name alone.

Can I put metal over shingles in Des Moines, Iowa?

Whether new roofing can go over existing layers depends on the number of layers, their condition, and the applicable code rules. Ask a roofer and check with the City Permit and Development Center before assuming an overlay is allowed for your roof.

Get help with roofing in Des Moines

If you are weighing metal against shingles for a Des Moines home, start with the condition of the roof you have. Call ZT Contracting LLC at (515) 385-2566 to arrange an inspection and talk through the options for your roof and your plans.

Tagged withmetal roofingasphalt shinglesdes moinesroof costhail damage

A few answers before you start.

Comparing metal and shingle roofing for your Des Moines home?

Call ZT Contracting LLC at (515) 385-2566 to arrange a roof inspection and talk through metal and shingle options for your roof.